10 Critical Articles on AI in Higher Ed: Sep. 2025

Posted on September 22, 2025 by JimS

By Jim Shimabukuro (assisted by Perplexity)
Editor

[Also see 10 Critical Articles on AI in Higher Ed: Oct. 2025]

Here are 10 of the most significant articles about AI in colleges and universities, published in September 2025.

1. The Question All Colleges Should Ask Themselves About AI (The Atlantic, Sept. 11, 2025)

Image created by Copilot.

This article investigates the core dilemma faced by higher education: how far universities should go to limit the harms of AI while reaping its benefits. With large language models becoming ubiquitous in student assignments and daily campus life, The Atlantic explores the rapidly blurring line between authentic learning and machine-facilitated shortcuts. The piece stands out because it addresses institutional responsibility — if unchecked, AI tools could subvert key goals like fostering critical thinking, accountability, and intellectual honesty. The article’s critical importance lies in forcing university leaders and faculty to confront substantial ambiguity. Should colleges ban, limit, or deeply integrate AI? The essay uses real-world case studies from diverse campuses, detailing efforts to develop innovative honor codes, AI-detection policies, and instructional redesigns meant to preserve learning value in a generative AI era. Its nuanced analysis avoids alarmism, focusing on system-wide adaptation and the risks of “letting the genie out of the bottle” without sufficient oversight—an essential read for anyone involved in education policy or teaching in 2025.theatlantic

2. The Death and Rebirth of Research in Education in the Age of AI (KU News, Sept. 22, 2025)

This article spotlights a transformative critique by three University of Kansas scholars on the status and future of educational research in the age of AI. They point out seven persistent challenges: peer review inefficiency, over-reliance on quantification, and the “tyranny of the typical,” among others. The authors argue that traditional research methods often produce findings of limited relevance for real-world classrooms, and these issues are intensified by the scale and speed of modern AI-driven analysis. The essay’s significance flows from its dual lens: while identifying fundamental limits of past educational research paradigms, it also highlights AI’s promise for reinvention. The authors encourage researchers to think of AI as both a cognitive partner and infrastructure—capable of democratizing research, enabling personalized inquiry, and making room for new, dynamic forms of knowledge production. Rather than treating AI as a threat or panacea, the essay calls for co-learning between humans and machines, ethical reflection, and a reorientation toward inquiry that is more innovative, equitable, and relevant. It is essential because it synthesizes both philosophical and practical guidance for the next generation of educational researchers.news.ku

3. Student Generative AI Survey 2025—HEPI (February 26, 2025)

This quantitative survey by HEPI details the unprecedented surge in generative AI usage among undergraduates, revealing that a majority now see AI chatbots as indispensable learning partners. The report’s importance lies in its mapping of rapid behavioral change: from 18% of staff considered “well-equipped” to deal with AI in 2024, jumping to 42% in 2025. This jump reveals an equally rapid maturation of staff development efforts and institutional policy responses. The survey is vital as it recommends urgent assessment reforms to prevent AI-based academic dishonesty, balanced AI integration policies, and sector-wide collaboration on best practices. Particularly significant is the report’s finding that the way students deploy AI is maturing — focused less on cheating, more on effective and ethical learning. For institutions, this marks a pivotal inflection point, suggesting the need for coordinated retraining and cross-institutional solutions to AI challenges that transcend single-college boundaries.hepi

4. Surveying the AI Landscape: Emerging Patterns in Higher Education Research (Digital Promise, July 31, 2025)

Published as a meta-analysis, this piece aggregates over 300 studies (2022–2025) that collectively map the adoption, impact, and evolving designs of generative AI in higher education. The article’s significance is twofold. First, it documents the global nature of this research, from the U.S. to China and Australia. Second, it identifies key research trends—in particular, the prominence of AI in writing and assessment, recurrent privacy concerns, and gaps in documentation of model configurations and deployments. This work is particularly valuable for showing how most research thus far targets undergraduate settings, with newer work expanding into graduate teaching, nursing, and continuing education. The meta-analysis not only provides an empirical foundation for further inquiry but calls attention to the need for more diverse, transparent, and ethically informed exploration of AI in academia.digitalpromise

5. Building AI Literacy: Critical Approaches and Pedagogical Applications (SUNY New Paltz FDC, Summer 2025)

This timely article, part of a broader September journal issue, focuses on strategies for empowering students with sustainable AI literacy. It stands out by stressing the importance of mutual trust and open conversation between faculty and students about the transformative effect of new technologies. The essay argues that disciplinary and pedagogical silos must be broken down to turn AI’s “tsunami” of change into opportunities for innovation, critical thinking, and ethical reasoning. Rather than relying on prescriptive bans or punishments, the article advocates for dialogic, student-centered practices that keep human relationships and classroom communities at the core. As universities wrestle with top-down policy versus bottom-up transformation, this vision positions AI integration as a learning partnership.Thresholds

6. How Will AI Influence Higher Ed in 2025? (Inside Higher Ed, Dec. 19, 2024)

Inside Higher Ed’s 2025 outlook presents a series of faculty and administrative predictions about AI’s integration. It highlights strong consensus that ignoring AI is no longer an option; instead, the most forward-thinking universities will treat AI as critical infrastructure for student support, institutional management, and research. The essay underscores the coming shift toward universal AI literacy requirements—projecting a near-term future in which every graduate will have substantial exposure to AI. Of particular importance is its focus on accountability, ethical governance, and equity: as AI becomes embedded across operations, transparency, bias mitigation, and student privacy will become non-negotiable institutional responsibilities.insidehighered

7. Making AI Generative for Higher Education (Ithaka S+R, May 1, 2025)

Drawing from longitudinal research and interviews at 19 North American universities, this report documents how postsecondary instructors and administrators are reacting to generative AI — from launching campus-wide task forces and workshops to rethinking pedagogical and policy frameworks. The article stands out by highlighting the ongoing tension between innovation and risk: the pace of AI change outstrips universities’ ability to craft robust integrity policies or fully understand financial implications. The value of this report is its nuanced exploration of both opportunities (AI literacy, personalized support) and obstacles (siloed governance, assessment integrity), positioning it as a handbook for practical leadership during AI-driven educational transformation.ithaka

8. Major Organizations Commit to Supporting AI Education (White House, Sept. 9, 2025)

This article highlights policy outcomes from leading stakeholders, industry, and the federal government, showcasing public-private commitments to advance equitable and responsible AI literacy for all students. Its significance lies in its narrative of alignment: as AI equity becomes a national policy imperative, universities are mobilizing to support inclusion and bridge existing digital divides. By documenting these institutional and governmental commitments, the piece offers hope that the benefits of AI will be extended to all, not just “elite” campuses, foregrounding the intersection of technology, access, and social justice.whitehouse

9. 2025 AI in Education: A Microsoft Special Report (Microsoft, June/Sept. 2025)

Produced by a global technology leader, this report synthesizes global case studies showing how universities are using AI to enhance student agency through adaptive tools that personalize learning. Its importance lies in moving beyond speculation to concrete impact: AI-supported learning pathways, on-demand tutoring, and “just-in-time” feedback are now realities in mainstream university settings. The essay pays significant attention to the challenges of scaling and local adaptation, painting a complex but hopeful picture in which global standards meet diverse educational needs.cdn-dynmedia-1.microsoft

10. UNESCO Survey: Guidance on AI Use in Higher Education (UNESCO, Sept. 2, 2025)

UNESCO’s report presents global survey results showing that two-thirds of higher education institutions have implemented, or are developing, formal guidance on AI use. The policy synthesis emphasizes not only technological adaptation, but also inclusive, human-centered frameworks for AI integration, policy development, and learning assessment. The article’s importance is in demonstrating that universities worldwide are not merely reacting — they are proactively shaping the role of AI in advancing educational outcomes, equity, and student empowerment on a global scale.unesco

  1. https://www.theatlantic.com/culture/archive/2025/09/ai-colleges-universities-solution/684160/
  2. https://news.ku.edu/news/article/ku-scholars-outline-death-and-rebirth-of-research-in-education-in-the-age-of-ai
  3. https://www.hepi.ac.uk/reports/student-generative-ai-survey-2025/
  4. https://digitalpromise.org/2025/07/31/surveying-the-ai-landscape-emerging-patterns-in-higher-education-research/
  5. https://hawksites.newpaltz.edu/fdc/2025-articles-resources/
  6. https://www.insidehighered.com/news/tech-innovation/artificial-intelligence/2024/12/19/how-will-ai-influence-higher-ed-2025
  7. https://sr.ithaka.org/publications/making-ai-generative-for-higher-education/
  8. https://www.whitehouse.gov/articles/2025/09/major-organizations-commit-to-supporting-ai-education/
  9. https://cdn-dynmedia-1.microsoft.com/is/content/microsoftcorp/microsoft/bade/documents/products-and-services/en-us/education/2025-Microsoft-AI-in-Education-Report.pdf
  10. https://www.unesco.org/en/articles/unesco-survey-two-thirds-higher-education-institutions-have-or-are-developing-guidance-ai-use
  11. https://hai.stanford.edu/ai-index/2025-ai-index-report
  12. https://www.insidehighered.com/news/tech-innovation/artificial-intelligence/2025/08/01/universities-meet-just-fraction-demand-ai
  13. https://www.brookings.edu/articles/generative-ai-is-coming-for-our-students-and-now-is-the-moment-to-shape-it/
  14. https://studyfinds.org/college-students-say-learning-ai-most-important-skill/
  15. http://acceleratelearning.stanford.edu/story/the-future-is-already-here-ai-and-education-in-2025/
  16. https://www.unesco.org/en/articles/ai-and-future-education-disruptions-dilemmas-and-directions
  17. https://www.unesco.org/en/digital-education/artificial-intelligence
  18. https://www.aacsb.edu/insights/articles/2023/10/how-ai-is-reshaping-higher-education
  19. https://library.educause.edu/topics/infrastructure-and-research-technologies/artificial-intelligence-ai

Filed under: 10 Critical Articles on AI in Higher Ed |

« »

Leave a comment